‘Over my dead body’ – Proposals to require some patients to pay for care provoke opposition

Photo of author

By Creative Media News

Strikes, salary, and an ageing populace are among the obstacles the NHS must overcome to provide free care for life.

The NHS winter crisis has been a challenge for both patients and staff. But it has also sparked a long-overdue and essential discussion about its viability and future.

There are many, such as former health secretary Sajid Javid, who believe that charging patients who can afford it is the way forward for the free cradle-to-grave service.

Wes Streeting, the shadow health secretary, responded to this idea with “Over my dead body!

Defenders of the NHS as a free-for-all service, such as former Labour Prime Minister Gordon Brown, warned that this will create a two-tier system that fails the neediest.

'over my dead body' - proposals to require some patients to pay for care provoke opposition
'over my dead body' - proposals to require some patients to pay for care provoke opposition

The National Health Service

All parties agree, however, that the NHS needs reform to stop summer and winter crises.

The National Health Service was originally intended to serve a completely different population. Due to breakthroughs in science and medicine, individuals live significantly longer nowadays.

But the fact that individuals are living longer does not necessarily indicate that they are healthy. Also an aging population, many of which have complicated comorbidities, poses significant challenges.

Professor Kiran Patel, the chief medical officer of University Hospitals Coventry & Warwickshire, has assisted with regional and national health planning for the future.

Prof. Patel states, “We could always claim that planning should have been better, but we’ve been planning for decades.”

We know the public has high expectations and prioritises technology and digital health care.”

We can already observe its effect on patient waiting lists, which currently exceed seven million.

Prof. Patel maintains, however, that the pandemic’s legacy is not wholly negative.

Proposals to require some patients to pay for care provoke opposition

The epidemic has compelled us to incorporate a great deal of that [new technology] and to begin preparing our staff and services for the future with a bit more clarity,” he explained.

The question of the labor force is crucial. There are now approximately 165,000 openings in the NHS.

If their demands are not granted, ambulance workers, nurses, and hospital employees will prolong their strike for weeks.

They are exhausted, demoralized, and underappreciated.

In November 2022, Health Secretary Steve Barclay identified the NHS’s five immediate objectives.

They were increasing staffing for NHS 111 and 999 services, focusing on urgent and emergency care, addressing delays in hospital discharge, enhancing access to primary care, and investing in technology.

Some health leaders criticized him harshly at the time for failing to acknowledge the staffing crisis.

Wes Streeting, commenting on the future of our health service after the first wave of healthcare strikes, used strong language.

He stated that the NHS was in an “existential crisis” and claimed that his party will train additional personnel, employ the private sector to reduce waiting lists, and implement decent wages and working conditions.

However, he has also been criticized for describing the Opposition’s plans for GP reform, stating that a Labour administration would “rip up the contract” with GPs and make family physicians salaried NHS employees.

Patients will be charged £20 for GP appointments and £66 for emergency visits without a referral under Sajid Javid’s proposal. The proposal will be faced with significant criticism from frontline medical professionals.

University Hospitals Coventry & Warwickshire

The director of emergency medicine at University Hospitals Coventry & Warwickshire, Dr. Ed Hartley, would oppose any attempts to implement fees.

According to him, that would not solve the crisis. Instead, he desires to reform and investment in crucial sectors such as social care and employee recruitment and retention.

“I want to see [more funding] for social care, and I want to see hospitals with the correct number of beds. We’ve lost thousands of hospital beds over the past decade. But we need to figure out what the right number is as a population.

“I am looking for system leadership. I’d like to see the NHS engage with local authorities and community health providers to solve difficulties and make long-term investments in the workforce.”

Dr. Hartley asserts that additional financing will assist in resolving many of the health service’s issues. But only if it is allocated to long-term solutions.

He said: “The National Health Service (NHS) can be repaired with the correct allocation of resources. Short-term measures, such as putting a holding pen for ambulances in front of the emergency area, do not fix the NHS. Short-term schemes to purchase hotel rooms for nursing home patients or hospitalized patients who must leave do not improve the NHS.

“Long-term investment in the workforce, long-term investment in the appropriate size of hospitals. Recognizing the care industry as a pleasant career with growth and, hopefully, adequate remuneration will help the NHS.”

Read More

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Skip to content