12.3 C
Thursday, May 23, 2024
HomeSportsBorthwick wants more World Cup refereeing transparency.

Borthwick wants more World Cup refereeing transparency.

  1. Calls for Openness and Consistency in Refereeing Decisions at Rugby World Cup
  2. Controversies Surrounding Red Cards and Bunker Reviews
  3. Opinions on TMO Use and Its Impact on the Game

England’s head coach, Steve Borthwick, has demanded more openness regarding refereeing decisions at the Rugby World Cup. As the sport’s disciplinary structure is scrutinised, his predecessor, Eddie Jones, criticised television replays.

Tom Curry was sent off within three minutes of last week’s victory over Argentina, making him the fourth England player to be dismissed in six matches. While he accepted his punishment, similar incidents involving South Africa’s Jesse Kriel, Chile’s Martin Sigren, Wales’ Dan Biggar, and France’s Romain Taofifénua were not deemed worthy of a red card.

This has led to accusations of inconsistent officiating at the World Cup, as Sigren and Taofifénua were sent to the “bunker” for review, whereas Kriel and Biggar were not punished. TMO rulings are public, but bunker review decisions are not. On Friday, Borthwick became the latest head coach to appeal for consistency and clarity.

Borthwick stated before England’s Sunday match against Japan, “In terms of the card situation, what we all want is consistency and probably some transparency around the decision-making process, but for us, we’ll focus on what we can control and what we know, which is our performance on Sunday.

“Our goal is to always have 15 players on the stage. Regarding our discipline and card situation, we wish to ensure that we do not possess any cards.

In terms of discipline, however, we conceded seven penalties last week. Therefore, I believe you observe a team that is attempting to be disciplined. That’s our objective.”

Borthwick continued by highlighting the disparity between World Rugby’s willingness to appeal against the initial decision to rescind Owen Farrell’s red card last month and the governing body’s relative reluctance to speak on disciplinary matters at the tournament. “It has been said and noted that there has been a great deal of commentary from various sources about what appears to be a lack of consistency and transparency in the decision-making process. Now, it is not my responsibility to comment on this; it is World Rugby’s.

“Owen Farrell was also the subject of much World Rugby commentary during our tournament preparation. It was a situation that drew extensive commentary from World Rugby. According to what I’ve heard, World Rugby has not made many comments in the last week or so. That is a matter for World Rugby.”

Jones believes that the use of the TMO diminishes the spectacle of the game. To avoid lengthy delays, a limited number of replays of incidents under review have been shown, but as a result, supporters are perplexed as to why decisions are being made.

“I’ve always said the game needs to be more continuous, the average ball-in-play is 30 seconds and the average break in the game is 70 seconds, so you encourage a power contest,” said Jones, whose Australia team faces Fiji on Sunday. “I believe more continuous action is required.

“Rugby’s use of the TMO is fraught with danger.” They are requesting that a referee in the stands make decisions based on a separate video angle of the game.

It does not make the game a greater spectacle, nor does it make the game better for the players.

“We are fortunate that international rugby is so well-liked. There were 50,000 spectators in Lille [on Thursday night] to witness France play Uruguay. We played a [warm-up] match against France in front of 80,000 spectators.

“Due to its nationalism and patriotism, international rugby supporters will watch anything on the pitch. But we must significantly enhance the game. After this World Cup, I believe that opportunity will arise.”

If Jones and other coaches could advise World Rugby collectively to improve the process, he said, “They don’t know.”

Wednesday, World Rugby and France 2023, the tournament’s administrators, discussed the quality of refereeing thus far.

Refereeing is one of the hardest jobs in sports, thus we must encourage them constantly. Due to its nationalism and patriotism, international rugby supporters will watch anything on the pitch.

World Rugby is reportedly concerned about social media’s use of still photographs to assess players.

A spokesperson for World Rugby added, “The citing window is 36 hours, and the citing commissioner has access to 15 or 16 different video angles; they see everything.” If they also determine that there was no distinct or obvious head contact, the incident is not subject to disciplinary action.”

Read More


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most Popular

Water business may pay £3.5m as compensation

The proprietor of South West Water (SWW) has declared that it will provide approximately £3.5 million in compensation to customers who a parasite outbreak in Devon has impacted. The Pennon group also disclosed its financial results on Tuesday, which encompassed dividends that would be paid to shareholders. Devon MP Anthony Mangnall dubbed the announcement "tin-eared" and urged the group to either suspend its dividend offering or resign from its leadership.

Trump hush money trial: Cohen admits to stealing

Cohen's fourth and concluding day on the witness stand it occurred on Monday. His statements were the final witness testimony that the prosecution presented prior to concluding its case. The trial has now shifted to the defense, which is attempting to refute allegations that Trump falsified business records to conceal a hush-money payment to a former pornographic film actress, thereby bolstering his chances in the 2016 presidential election.

Scarlett Johansson ‘shocked and angered’ by AI voice recreation

Despite the CEO's apparent suggestion in a social media post that the tech company had intentionally copied the actress's intonation, the company has denied doing so. According to Scarlett Johansson, she was "shocked" and "angry" when OpenAI purportedly replicated her voice without her permission for a new ChatGPT system. The actress personally criticized Sam Altman, the company's CEO, in a statement for suggesting that she was the voice of 'Sky' by publishing the word 'her' on X. This reference was to a film in which she portrayed an AI that a human fell in love with.

Truss blames Bank; markets deemed mini-Budget disastrous

In October 2022, the then-Chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng arrived at the temporary residence of Britain's Ambassador to Washington, Dame Karen Pierce, on a wet and windy night in Washington, D.C. He appeared to be a man without a care in the world.  As the English sparkling wine poured, his extrovert hostess, who was colorfully attired, appeared equally at ease.

Recent Comments